What is menu engineering?
Menu engineering is the strategic process of analyzing and designing a restaurant's menu to maximize profitability and customer satisfaction. It involves categorizing items by popularity and profit, optimizing pricing, layout, and descriptions to influence customer choices and boost sales.
The Ultimate Guide to Restaurant Menu Engineering
Introduction to Restaurant Menu Engineering
Your restaurant's menu is much more than just a list of food and drinks - it's one of the most important tools to attract customers and increase your profits. Studies show that up to 70% of a restaurant's sales come from just 20% of the menu items. This means how you arrange and present your menu can make a big difference in what customers order and how much money you make.
Menu engineering is all about understanding which dishes are popular and profitable, and then using that information to design a menu that encourages guests to pick those items. It includes choosing the right prices, organizing the menu layout so customers see the best dishes first, and writing descriptions that make food sound delicious.
If done well, menu engineering helps you boost sales without pushing customers to spend more than they want. It can also improve the overall dining experience by making choices clear and appealing.
Understanding Menu Item Classification
One of the most important parts of menu engineering is learning how to classify your menu items. This helps you understand which dishes bring in the most money and which ones might be holding you back. Experts often divide menu items into four categories based on two key things - how popular they are with customers and how much profit they make. These categories are called Stars, Plowhorses, Puzzles, and Dogs.
1. Stars are the best performers. They are both popular and profitable. These are the dishes customers love to order, and they bring in a good profit margin for your restaurant. Because they do so well, you want to make sure these items stand out on your menu. Highlighting Stars can encourage even more customers to choose them.
2. Plowhorses are popular but don't make much profit. Maybe they cost a lot to prepare or you price them too low. Even though many customers order them, they don't bring in much money. To fix this, you might try raising the price carefully or finding ways to reduce the cost of making these dishes.
3. Puzzles are profitable but not very popular. These items make good money when ordered, but customers don't choose them often. Sometimes, a better description or placing the dish in a more visible spot on the menu can increase its popularity.
4. Dogs are the worst performers. They're neither popular nor profitable. These items often take up space on the menu and in the kitchen but don't help your business. Consider removing or replacing Dogs to free up resources for better options.
By sorting your menu this way, you get a clearer picture of where to focus your attention. It helps you know what to promote, what to fix, and what to remove. This classification is a simple but powerful tool for improving your menu and increasing your profits.
Simplify Multi-Channel Ordering
Get started with Altametrics to streamline your POS!
Pricing Strategies for Maximizing Profit
Pricing your menu items the right way is key to making sure your restaurant stays profitable. If prices are too high, customers might avoid ordering certain dishes. If they're too low, you could lose money or miss out on profits. Finding the right balance is part of menu engineering.
1. Use Psychological Pricing
Set prices just below a round number, like $9.99 instead of $10. This small change makes the price feel lower and encourages customers to order more.
2. Apply Price Anchoring
Include a very expensive item on your menu to make other dishes seem like better deals. For example, a $50 steak makes a $30 chicken dish look more affordable, nudging customers to pick mid-range items that often have better profit margins.
3. Calculate Food Costs Carefully
Know how much it costs to make each dish. Ideally, your food cost should be about 25-35% of the menu price. For instance, if a dish costs $5 to prepare, pricing it between $15 and $20 can ensure a good profit.
4. Make Small Price Adjustments
Avoid big jumps in prices. Instead, increase prices gradually so customers don't feel shocked or turned away.
5. Compare Local Competitors
Check what similar restaurants nearby charge. Your prices should be competitive - not too high to scare customers away, and not too low to undervalue your food.
By following these five pricing strategies, you can set prices that attract customers while helping your restaurant stay financially healthy and successful.
Strategic Menu Layout and Design Principles
How your menu looks plays a big role in what customers decide to order. A well-designed menu helps guide guests' eyes toward the dishes you want to promote, making it easier for them to choose and increasing your chances of selling higher-profit items. Here are some important design tips to keep in mind when arranging your menu -
1. Use Visual Hierarchy
People naturally look at certain parts of the menu first. Studies show that customers often focus on the top right corner of the menu. Place your best-selling or most profitable dishes in this area to catch attention quickly. You can also use boxes, borders, or background colors to make important sections stand out.
2. Highlight Signature Dishes
Make your star items easy to spot by using icons, different fonts, or colors. For example, a small chef's hat or a star symbol can signal a popular choice. This helps customers quickly identify what you recommend and builds confidence in their decision.
3. Keep It Simple and Clean
Avoid cluttering the menu with too many items or complicated designs. A clean layout with plenty of white space makes it easier for customers to read and understand their choices. Use clear headings and organize items logically by category (appetizers, mains, desserts, etc.).
4. Use Fonts and Colors Wisely
Choose fonts that are easy to read. Avoid using too many different fonts or bright colors that can be hard on the eyes. Instead, stick to two or three fonts and a color scheme that fits your restaurant's style. Colors can also influence appetite; warm colors like red and orange tend to increase hunger.
5. Place Prices Strategically
Rather than lining up prices in a neat column, consider placing them right next to the item description or using a slightly smaller font. This helps customers focus more on the dish itself rather than just the cost.
By thoughtfully arranging your menu with these design principles, you can make the ordering experience easier and encourage guests to select dishes that boost your profits while enjoying their meal.
Menu Item Descriptions that Sell
The way you describe your menu items can make a big difference in what customers decide to order. A well-written description doesn't just list ingredients - it creates an image, a feeling, or a craving in the customer's mind. Here are some tips to help you write descriptions that sell -
1. Use Sensory Words
Words that appeal to the senses - taste, smell, texture, and appearance - help customers imagine the dish. Instead of saying chicken with sauce, try tender grilled chicken glazed with a smoky barbecue sauce. This makes the dish sound more tempting and vivid.
2. Keep It Simple and Clear
While it's important to be descriptive, avoid making the descriptions too long or complicated. Customers want to understand what they're ordering quickly. Use short, easy-to-read phrases that highlight the main features of the dish.
3. Highlight Freshness and Quality
Mention if ingredients are fresh, local, or organic. For example, "freshly picked garden herbs" or "locally sourced vegetables" show care and quality, which can justify a higher price and attract health-conscious customers.
4. Tell a Story
Sometimes, a brief story about the dish's origin or inspiration can add interest. For example, "A classic Italian recipe passed down through generations" can make the dish feel special and authentic.
5. Avoid Overused Words
Try not to rely too much on generic adjectives like "delicious" or "tasty," which don't say much. Instead, use specific words that describe the flavor, texture, or cooking method.
6. Use Alliteration and Rhymes (Carefully)
Fun language tricks like alliteration (crispy, creamy crab cakes) can catch the eye and make the item more memorable - but don't overdo it.
Good menu descriptions help customers feel confident and excited about their choice. They also set expectations, reducing confusion and improving satisfaction. By investing time in crafting appealing, clear, and tempting descriptions, you can guide customers toward your best dishes and increase sales.
Leveraging Data and Analytics
Using data to understand how your menu is performing is one of the smartest ways to improve your restaurant's profitability. Without clear information, it's hard to know which dishes are winning and which might need changes. Menu engineering relies heavily on tracking sales and profit data for each item so you can make informed decisions.
First, start by collecting basic sales data. This means knowing how many times each dish sells over a set period, such as a week or a month. Point-of-sale (POS) systems can automatically track this for you, making it easy to see your top sellers and slow movers.
Next, combine sales data with profit information. Look at how much money each dish brings in after considering ingredient costs and preparation time. Some items may sell a lot but have a low profit margin, while others might sell less but make more money per order. Understanding this helps you classify your menu items (like Stars, Plowhorses, Puzzles, and Dogs) and decide where to focus your efforts.
Many restaurants use menu engineering software or analytics tools that provide clear reports and even suggest pricing or placement changes. These tools save time and give you valuable insights you might miss otherwise.
It's important to review your menu data regularly. Tastes and trends change, so an item that was popular last year might not be now. By monitoring your menu's performance often, you can make adjustments to pricing, descriptions, or layout to keep your menu fresh and profitable.
Finally, don't forget to collect customer feedback alongside data. Sometimes the numbers don't tell the whole story - customers might have reasons for not ordering certain dishes, like portion size or ingredient preferences.
Optimizing Menu Size and Variety
Finding the right balance between variety and simplicity is crucial when designing your restaurant menu. Offering too many items can overwhelm customers and slow down kitchen operations, while too few options might leave diners feeling limited and less interested. Optimizing menu size and variety helps improve both customer satisfaction and your restaurant's efficiency.
A menu that's too large can confuse guests. When faced with too many choices, customers may feel stressed or take longer to decide, which can hurt the overall dining experience. Additionally, a large menu often means more ingredients to stock, higher food waste, and longer prep times. This can lead to increased costs and kitchen chaos.
On the other hand, a very small menu limits the options for different tastes and dietary needs, which may push some customers away. Variety is important to attract a wider audience and keep regular guests interested with new or seasonal items.
To find the right balance, review your menu regularly and focus on the dishes that perform best. Use sales data and customer feedback to identify which items are popular and profitable, and consider removing or reworking those that don't sell well. Seasonal menus are a great way to keep variety fresh without overwhelming the kitchen all year round.
Also, grouping similar dishes together in clear categories (like appetizers, mains, sides, and desserts) helps customers navigate the menu more easily. Offering customizable options, such as add-ons or different portion sizes, can give guests flexibility without adding too many separate menu items.
Continuous Menu Testing and Improvement
Menu engineering isn't a one-time task - it's an ongoing process. Customer preferences, food costs, and market trends constantly change, so regularly reviewing and updating your menu is essential to stay competitive and profitable.
Start by testing small changes, such as adjusting prices, updating descriptions, or rearranging items on the menu. You can use A/B testing by offering different versions of your menu to see which performs better. Collect customer feedback through surveys or direct conversations to understand what they like or want improved.
Regularly monitor your sales and profit data to spot trends or slow-selling dishes. If an item isn't performing well despite changes, consider replacing it with a new option or seasonal special. Keep an eye on ingredient costs too, so you can adjust prices or recipes as needed without sacrificing quality.
Staying flexible and open to change allows you to create a menu that not only appeals to your guests but also supports your business goals.
Ready to take your menu engineering to the next level? Altametrics offers powerful restaurant analytics tools that help you track sales, analyze menu performance, and make data-driven decisions easily. Their platform provides clear insights to optimize pricing, manage costs, and improve your menu continuously - all in one place.
Click "Book a Demo" below today and discover how smart analytics can help you boost profits and delight your customers every time.
Must-Read Content
Create restaurant menu
How to Create Restaurant Menu Boards
Design a restaurant menu
How to Design a Restaurant Menu That Increases Sales
Menu for restaurant
How to Use Data to Optimize Your Menu for Restaurant Performance
Restaurant menu layout
Top 5 Restaurant Menu Layout Trends in 2025
Frequently Asked Questions
What are Puzzle items in menu engineering?
Puzzles are dishes that have high profit margins but low popularity, meaning they sell less frequently despite being profitable.
What tools can help with menu engineering?
Point-of-sale systems, menu engineering software, and analytics platforms like Altametrics can track sales and suggest menu improvements.
How do I know if my prices are too high or too low?
Compare prices with local competitors, monitor sales trends, and watch customer reactions to find the right balance.
What is price anchoring and how does it work?
Price anchoring is placing a very expensive item on your menu to make other dishes seem more reasonably priced, encouraging customers to choose mid-range options.
