What You Will Learn
Discover how to identify which menu items truly boost your restaurant's profits and which may be costing you more than they're worth. Learn how to calculate true food costs, analyze menu profitability, categorize dishes for better decision-making, and apply practical strategies to improve margins. Plus, find out why regular monitoring and the right tools are key to long-term success.
Are Your Menu Items Costing You More Than They're Worth?
When Popular Dishes Drain Profits
Running a restaurant means you want your menu to please customers and keep them coming back. It's normal to feel proud of certain dishes that everyone seems to love. But here's something many restaurant owners don't realize - just because a dish is popular doesn't mean it's making you money. In fact, some of your top-selling meals might be costing you more than they earn.
Studies show that many restaurants lose up to 20% of their potential profits because they don't keep a close eye on food costs. This often happens when owners focus only on how many dishes sell, without checking how much those dishes really cost to make.
The real cost of a menu item goes beyond just the ingredients. You need to consider waste, preparation time, and even small extras like sauces or garnishes. Without understanding these details, it's easy to make decisions based on guesswork, which can hurt your business in the long run.
The True Cost of a Menu Item
When you look at your menu, it's tempting to think the cost of a dish is just the price of the ingredients. But in reality, the true cost of a menu item includes much more. Knowing this full cost is key to controlling food expenses and protecting your profits.
First, start with the basic ingredients - the meat, vegetables, spices, and everything else that goes directly into the dish. This is called the food cost or cost of goods sold (COGS). But that's only part of the picture.
Next, consider the hidden costs that add up quickly. For example, small things like cooking oil, sauces, garnishes, or even bread served on the side might seem minor but can add significantly to the total cost. Also, think about waste - trimmings, peelings, or leftover scraps that don't end up on a plate but cost money to buy.
Preparation time is another factor. Some dishes take longer to make or require special skills, which means higher labor costs. While this isn't always included in food cost calculations, it's important to remember that complex dishes can cost more in time and effort.
To understand if a dish is worth it, restaurant owners often use the food cost percentage, which compares how much a dish costs to make against its selling price. The formula looks like this -
Food Cost % = (Cost of Ingredients / Menu Price) x 100
For example, if a dish costs $4 to make and sells for $12, the food cost percentage is about 33%. Most restaurants aim for food costs between 28% and 32%, depending on the style and pricing strategy.
By knowing these numbers, you can better decide which dishes are truly profitable and which might need adjustment. It's about seeing the full story behind each plate, not just the surface.
Why Menu Price Doesn't Equal Profit
It's easy to assume that if a dish sells for a high price, it must be bringing in lots of profit. But the truth is, the menu price alone doesn't tell the whole story about how much money you're actually making. Understanding this difference is important to avoid surprises when the bills come in.
Think about it this way - the money a customer pays for a dish is your sales revenue, but it doesn't all turn into profit. From that amount, you have to cover the cost of ingredients and other expenses before you see what's left over. If the ingredients for a dish are expensive, you might only be making a small margin - even if it looks like a big sale on paper.
Many restaurant owners aim for a food cost percentage around 28% to 32%. That means for every dollar the customer spends, about 28 to 32 cents goes to the cost of the food itself. But food cost is just one part of the expenses. You also have labor costs, rent, utilities, marketing, and other overheads. These all eat into your profits.
For example, a steak dish might sell for $30, which seems great, but if the food cost is $12 (40%), that's already higher than the ideal range. Add in labor to prepare it, and your actual profit shrinks even more.
By knowing this, you can see why some cheaper dishes with lower food costs can actually contribute more to your profit than expensive ones that cost too much to make. It's about balancing price and cost, not just chasing high menu prices.
Conducting a Menu Profitability Analysis
Knowing whether your menu items are truly profitable starts with a simple process called menu profitability analysis. This means taking a closer look at each dish to understand how much it costs to make and how much money it brings in. Doing this regularly gives you clear data to make smart decisions, instead of guessing which dishes help or hurt your bottom line.
Here's a straightforward way to analyze your menu items -
1. Calculate the Cost per Dish - Begin by adding up the cost of all ingredients used in each dish, including small extras like sauces and garnishes. Don't forget to factor in waste or shrinkage - food that's thrown away or lost during prep. This gives you the true cost to produce one serving.
2. Track Sales Volume - Next, check your sales records to see how many times each dish sells during a certain period, like a month. This tells you which items are popular and which don't sell much.
3. Identify High-Cost, Low-Margin Items - Now compare the cost per dish to its selling price. If a dish costs a lot but sells for a price that leaves a small margin, it might be dragging your profits down. Pay attention to items that don't sell often but still have high costs - these can tie up inventory and waste resources.
4. Compare Performance Across the Menu - Look at all your dishes side by side. Which ones bring in the most profit overall? Which ones sell well but don't earn much? Which items rarely sell but cost a lot? This comparison helps you see where adjustments may be needed.
To help with this process, many restaurants use tools like point-of-sale (POS) systems or spreadsheets. These tools make it easier to gather data and visualize which dishes are stars and which need rethinking.
Regularly doing this analysis will give you the clear insight needed to control food costs and keep your restaurant profitable.
Menu Engineering Basics
Once you've gathered the data on your menu items' costs and sales, it's helpful to organize them into categories. This approach, called menu engineering, groups dishes by how popular they are and how much profit they generate. It gives you a clear picture of which items are working well and which may need attention.
There are four main categories to know -
1. Stars - These are the dishes that sell well and make good profit. They are your best performers. Stars keep customers happy and help your bottom line. You want to keep these items on your menu and promote them when possible.
2. Plowhorses - These dishes sell in high volume but don't bring in as much profit because their costs are higher or prices are lower. They're popular with guests but can cut into your margins. With plowhorses, small adjustments like tweaking portions or ingredients might boost profitability without hurting sales.
3. Puzzles - Puzzles are dishes that have high profit margins but don't sell well. They have potential but may need better marketing or menu placement to attract more orders. Sometimes a better description or highlighting the item can increase sales.
4. Dogs - These items neither sell well nor bring in good profit. Dogs can take up space on your menu and confuse customers. It's usually best to remove or rethink these dishes to free up room for better options.
By placing your menu items into these four groups, you make decisions based on facts - not just feelings or tradition. This method helps you focus on improving dishes that can grow profits and removing those that cost more than they're worth.
Transform Your Restaurant Operations Now!
Effortless Inventory Tracking with Altametrics!
Strategies to Improve Item Profitability
After finding out which menu items are costing you too much, it's time to make changes. Improving profitability doesn't mean lowering quality or upsetting customers. Instead, focus on smart, practical steps that help your restaurant succeed.
Here are five key strategies to improve the profitability of your menu items -
1. Adjust Portion Sizes
Reducing the amount of costly ingredients or sides slightly can cut costs without customers noticing. For example, trimming a little meat or using less garnish adds up to big savings over time.
2. Substitute Ingredients
Swap expensive ingredients for more affordable options that don't affect taste. Using seasonal or locally sourced vegetables can lower costs and boost freshness.
3. Raise Prices Strategically
If a dish is popular and unique, customers might accept a small price increase. Make changes carefully and test slowly to avoid losing business.
4. Improve Menu Descriptions and Presentation
Using words like "house-made," "fresh," or "locally sourced" can increase perceived value, helping justify higher prices without changing the food.
5. Base Decisions on Data, Not Guesswork
Always use your cost and sales data to guide changes. Avoid gut-feeling adjustments, and track results to see what works best.
By following these steps, you can turn costly dishes into stronger profit-makers while keeping your customers happy and coming back for more.
Monitoring Over Time, Not Just Once
Controlling food costs and keeping your menu profitable isn't something you do just once and forget about. It's an ongoing process. Food prices change, customer preferences shift, and even small changes in your kitchen can affect how much your dishes cost to prepare. That's why regular monitoring is essential.
For example, ingredient prices often fluctuate due to seasonality, supply shortages, or changes from your suppliers. A vegetable that's cheap in summer might become expensive in winter. If you don't adjust your menu or portions accordingly, your food costs can quietly rise without you realizing it.
Waste patterns can also change over time. Maybe your kitchen staff has found a better way to prepare a dish, reducing waste, or perhaps new staff members need training to avoid over-portioning. Keeping an eye on waste and prep habits helps control hidden costs that add up fast.
Your menu itself may need adjustments as tastes evolve. Some dishes might become less popular, while others gain momentum. Regularly reviewing sales and profitability data helps you spot these trends and make informed decisions on what to promote, revise, or remove.
Many successful restaurant owners schedule monthly or quarterly menu reviews. During these reviews, they check food cost percentages, sales numbers, and any changes in supplier pricing. This practice ensures you're never caught off guard and can react quickly to protect profits.
Remember, managing food cost is a marathon, not a sprint. By making menu analysis and cost control a regular habit, you create a stronger, more resilient restaurant that can adapt to challenges and continue to grow.
Profitable Menus Start with Hard Data
Running a profitable restaurant isn't just about cooking great food - it's about making smart, informed decisions every day. When it comes to your menu, popularity alone won't guarantee success. You need clear, accurate data on costs, sales, and waste to understand which dishes truly contribute to your bottom line.
Taking the time to analyze your menu items, monitor costs regularly, and adjust based on facts - not feelings - will help you keep your food costs under control and your profits healthy. It's a continuous process that pays off by making your restaurant more efficient, competitive, and sustainable.
If managing inventory, tracking food costs, and analyzing menu profitability feels overwhelming, you don't have to do it alone. Tools like Altametrics can simplify this process by providing real-time inventory management and food cost control tailored specifically for restaurants. Altametrics helps you track ingredient usage, reduce waste, and get instant insights into which menu items are making or losing money.
By combining your knowledge with the right technology, you can take full control of your food costs and build a menu that's not only loved by your customers but also profitable for your business.
Explore how Altametrics can help you manage your inventory and food costs more effectively by clicking "Schedule a Demo" below.
Efficient Ordering at Your Fingertips
Experience Flawless Inventory Management with Altametrics
Employee scheduling
The Complete Guide to Restaurant Employee Benefits
Accounting payroll
5 Signs Your Hotel Needs to Upgrade Its Payment Processing System
Restaurant management
The Ultimate Daily Checklist for Restaurant Owners
Accounting payroll
Are You Over-complicating Your Restaurants Payroll Process?
Inventory management
Is Your Inventory Management Costing You Profits?
Employee scheduling
How Can Smart Scheduling Transform Your Restaurant's Efficiency?
Restaurant management
What Are the Best Email Marketing Campaign Ideas for Restaurants in 2025?
Restaurant management
How Can You Maintain Brand Consistency Across Multiple Franchise Locations?
Employee scheduling
How Can Restaurants Prevent Scheduling Conflicts and Last-Minute Absences?
Restaurant management
What's the Most Efficient Way to Manage Tasks in a Busy Restaurant?
Employee scheduling
What Should You Look for When Interviewing Restaurant Staff?
Restaurant management
What Is a Dram Shop Law and How Does It Affect Your Restaurant?
Restaurant management
What Features Should Every Restaurant Ordering System Have in 2025?
Accounting payroll
What Are the Most Cost-Effective Ways to Reduce Waste in a Restaurant?
Inventory management
Are Your Menu Items Costing You More Than They're Worth?
Accounting payroll
How Do You Handle Overtime and Tip Credit in Restaurant Payroll?
Accounting payroll
Are You Spending Too Much Time on Payroll? Here's How to Fix it
Inventory management
How Can I Implement an Effective Inventory Management System in my Restaurant?
Sales forecasting
What Do Consumer Reports Say About Your Menu?
Inventory management
What Are the Main Inventory Costing Methods for Restaurants?
Restaurant management
How to Streamline Your Restaurants Supply Chain
Restaurant management
How to Optimize Order Fulfillment in Your Restaurant
Employee scheduling
How to Design an Effective Employee Training Program for Restaurants
Restaurant management
9 Essential Workforce Management Tools Every Restaurant Needs
Accounting payroll
How to Read and Use Your Restaurants Profit and Loss Statement
Accounting payroll
How to Organize Your Restaurant's Financial Records Efficiently
Accounting payroll
Restaurant Billing 101 - Simplify Your Finances and Boost Efficiency
Accounting payroll
The Ultimate Guide to Accounts Payable Automation for Restaurant Owners
Accounting payroll
Benefits of Accounts Receivable Automation for Restaurants
Accounting payroll
The Ultimate Guide to Restaurant Accounting
Accounting payroll
Restaurant Bookkeeping 101 - A Beginner's Guide for Restaurant Owners
Accounting payroll
Invoice Management 101 - A Simple Guide for Restaurant Owners
Restaurant management
What Are Par Levels and Why Every Restaurant Owner Should Care
Sales forecasting
Top 5 Consumer Metrics Every Restaurant Should Track
Inventory management
Which Inventory Method is Best for Your Restaurant?
Accounting payroll
Setting Up an Employee Loan Program in Your Restaurant
Employee scheduling
The Ultimate Employee Onboarding Checklist for Restaurant Owners
Accounting payroll
Top 7 Payroll Mistakes Restaurant Owners Should Avoid
Accounting payroll
How to Calculate Food Cost Variance in Your Restaurant
Sales forecasting
A Guide to Understanding Customer Behavior in Restaurants
Restaurant management
Top 10 California Employment Laws Every Restaurant Owner Must Know
Restaurant management
How to Create Custom Recipe Templates for Your Restaurant Kitchen
Restaurant management
5 Practical Strategies to Cut Food Waste in Your Restaurant
Restaurant management
Understanding Restaurant Food Cost Percentage in 2025 - Strategies for Profitability
Inventory management
The Restaurant Owner's Guide to Streamlining Supply Chain Processes
Restaurant management
How to Efficiently Calculate and Manage Labor Cost in Restaurants
Food safety
General Food Safety Guidelines for Restaurants
Inventory management
A Guide for Restaurant Food Suppliers
Employee scheduling
Key Elements of a Successful Restaurant Scheduling System
Restaurant management
How to Reduce Labor Costs in Your Restaurant Without Sacrificing Service
Inventory management
5 Best Practices for Food Inventory Management to Reduce Waste
Employee scheduling
Understanding California Overtime Laws for Restaurants
Employee scheduling
Top Features to Look for in an Electronic Time Clock for Restaurants
Restaurant management
The Best Employee Rewards Programs for Restaurants
Employee scheduling
The Best Time Keeping Methods for Restaurants
Employee scheduling
How a Restaurant Scheduling App Helps You Avoid Common Scheduling Mistakes
Employee scheduling
Features to Look for in a Clock-In Machine for Restaurants
Employee scheduling
How to Improve Time and Attendance Tracking in Your Restaurant
Employee scheduling
How California Work Week Laws Affect Restaurant Scheduling
Accounting payroll
Best Practices for Calculating Payroll Hours in Restaurants
Employee scheduling
How to Prevent Time Theft in Your Restaurant
Restaurant management
How Technology Can Improve Employee Management in Restaurants
Employee scheduling
California Employment Laws Every Hotel Owner Should Know in 2025
Restaurant management
California's Updated Overtime and Break Laws for Restaurants
Employee scheduling
10 Essential Work Schedules for Running a Smooth Restaurant Operation
Employee scheduling
How to Accurately Calculate Work Hours for Your Restaurant Staff
Employee scheduling
Best Practices for Managing Employee Time and Attendance in Restaurants
Employee scheduling
How to Create an Efficient Restaurant Weekly Schedule That Boosts Productivity
Software integration
Top 5 Benefits of Automating Your Business Workflows
Software integration
The Role of AI in Business Process Automation
Software integration
The Power of API Integrations - Connecting Your Business Tools Seamlessly
Software integration
The Importance of Seamless Integrations in Today's Business Landscape
Software integration
How Workflow Automation Can Save Small Businesses Thousands of Dollars
Software integration
How Any Connector Simplifies API Integrations for Your Business
Software integration
Empowering Your Employees with Automation- A Win-Win Strategy
Software integration
Building a Business Case for Automation in Your Organization
Employee scheduling
Automation in Hospitality - Streamlining Guest Experiences
Restaurant management
5 Ways Restaurants Can Leverage Automation for Operational Success
Sales forecasting
How to Double Your Restaurant's Profit in 30 Days
Inventory management
The Ultimate Guide to Accurate Inventory Counting in Restaurants
Restaurant management
How to Transform Your Restaurant Operations
Restaurant management
How to Effectively Reduce Expenses and Increase Staff Engagement in Your Restaurant
Employee scheduling
How to make sure you will always meet labor goals before you run payroll
Employee scheduling
How to reduce labor costs without retraining your management team.
Restaurant management
3 top reasons your managers should always earn their bonuses
Software integration
How to guarantee your franchise technology rollout will be a success
Employee scheduling
How to reduce labor costs by 3-5% without ever using an excel spreadsheet again
Employee scheduling
How to find and keep your best employees
Software integration
Why your IT team has to provide better mobile apps for you to stay competitive
Accounting payroll
How to streamline your business operations test for maximum efficiency
Software integration
How to make sure your technology projects are on time and on budget
Employee scheduling
Why employee engagement and retention are the keys to improving profitability
Employee scheduling
The easy way to write great employee schedules
Restaurant management
How to manage your restaurant inventory planning to ensure you're never caught short
Inventory management
5 Basic Inventory Management Tips That Can Save You Money
Inventory management
Top 3 Reasons Why You Need Cloud-Based Inventory Management Software
Restaurant management
The Best Food Service Management Companies in the Industry
Software integration
7 Tips for Choosing the Best Restaurant Directory Software
Food safety
What You Need to Know About Food Tech Safety
Employee scheduling
The Top 5 Reasons To Use HR Reporting Software
Food safety
A Guide On What To Know About SQF Food Safety
Inventory management
10 Inventory Management Stock Control Tips For Your Business
Restaurant management
Issues Facing Multi-Chain Restaurants In 2022
Employee scheduling
The Benefits of HR Software Reporting For Professionals
Employee scheduling
5 Top HR Software Solutions To Consider For Your Business
Software integration
5 Reasons Why You Need Restaurant Menu Software
Employee scheduling
Tips for Retaining Hourly Restaurant Employees
Employee scheduling
Hurdles That Keep Restaurant Chains From Becoming The Employer Of Choice
Accounting payroll
Why You Should Start Using Restaurant Payroll Software
Inventory management
How To Make The Most Out Of Your Simple Inventory Management Software
Restaurant management
Food Waste Management- 6 Strategies to Reduce the Impact of Food Waste
Food safety
CDC Food Safety- The Important Perspective
Food safety
What To Know About Taking A Food Safety Class
Inventory management
The Average Restaurant Food Cost Percentage & What You Can Do About It
Inventory management
Inventory Management Best Practices- A Guide to Controlling Your Inventory
Software integration
How to Choose the Right Restaurant Dashboard Software for Your Needs
Inventory management
5 Free Inventory Management Tools for Small Businesses
Food safety
How to Get a Food and Drink Handling License
Employee scheduling
3 Ways You Can Get Your Employees to Love Cloud-based HR and Payroll Software
Inventory management
5 Ways to Improve Your Multi Channel Inventory Management
Inventory management
5 Top Ways to Reduce Your Restaurant Fixed Costs
Inventory management
The Best Inventory Management Software- The Ultimate Guide
Food safety
What To Know About A Food Safety Course Online
Employee scheduling
The Best Free Employee Scheduling Apps to Help Your Business Run Smoothly
Food safety
How To Identify PHF Food Safety Anywhere You Are
Restaurant management
5 Tips for Choosing the Best Kitchen Equipment Supplier
Software integration
Mobile Device Inventory Management- A Guide to Help You Do It Right
Food safety
Food Safety Zone- A Guide to Safely Eating Out
Restaurant management
3 Tips to Find the Best Restaurant Paper Suppliers
Inventory management
Top Free Inventory Management Software for Small Businesses
Food safety
7 Ways To Become A Food Safety Auditor
Employee scheduling
5 Reasons You Should Be Using Free HR Software
Inventory management
4 Types of Inventory Management Systems and How They Affect Your Business
Employee scheduling
HR Recruitment Software- Why Restaurant Chains Fail To Become Preferred Choice
Restaurant management
Food Waste Management Solutions- The Ultimate Guide to Eliminating Food Waste
Employee scheduling
HR Software Solutions- Tips For Retaining Hourly Restaurant Employees
Accounting payroll
What You Need to Know About Restaurant Payroll Laws
Employee scheduling
HR Software List- The Best and the Worst
Restaurant management
How Restaurant Food Suppliers Are Important To A Business
Restaurant management
What Are The Best Restaurant Paper Goods Suppliers?
Inventory management
The Ultimate Guide to Inventory Management Techniques
Food safety
Food Safety Tips- How To Stay Safe at Home
Restaurant management
5 Questions to Ask Yourself Before Hiring a Food Service Management Company
Restaurant management
Ordering Management System- Issues Faced by Multi-Chain Restaurants In 2022
Food safety
Three Steps to Creating a Food Safety Plan
Employee scheduling
The Best Employee Time Clock Machines for Your Business
Employee scheduling
The Top 5 Reasons to Switch to Cloud Based HR Software
Employee scheduling
Our Top 5 Best Employee Scheduling Apps For Small Businesses
Food safety
Food Safety News- A Checklist for Safe Foods
Restaurant management
8 Tips for Successful Financial Management In Food Service
Software integration
5 Tips for Improving Your Data Integration Software
Food safety
5 Benefits of Food Safety That You Need to Know
Employee scheduling
The Best Employee Shift Planning Manager | Employee Scheduling & Shift Planning
Employee scheduling
Free Employee Time Clock to Give Your Business a Competitive Edge
Restaurant management
The Best Restaurant Produce Suppliers in America
Employee scheduling
HR Timesheet Software- What To Look For and How It Works
Restaurant management
Find the Best Restaurant Chemical Suppliers
Employee scheduling
Tracking Time Effectively- The Best HR Time Tracking Software
Accounting payroll
5 Best Business Accounting Software Reviews
Employee scheduling
5 Free Employee Scheduling Apps You Need to Try
Restaurant management
How to Find the Best Restaurant Coffee Suppliers
Frequently Asked Questions
Are there tools that can help me track food costs better?
Yes. Inventory management tools like Altametrics provide real-time tracking of ingredient usage, waste, and sales, making it easier to understand food costs and improve profitability.
How do I calculate the true cost of a menu item beyond just ingredients?
Besides ingredient costs, include hidden expenses like cooking oil, garnishes, condiments, and waste from prep. Factoring these in gives you a more accurate picture of what each dish truly costs to make.
How can technology help with menu cost control?
Technology like inventory management and POS systems track ingredient use, sales, and waste in real time. This data helps spot costly items quickly and supports smarter purchasing and pricing decisions.
How can tracking sales volume help control food costs?
Knowing how often each dish sells helps you manage inventory better, reduce waste, and decide which items to promote or remove based on popularity and profitability.
