What you will learn
Discover how to identify the right qualities in restaurant job candidates, including work ethic, communication, and adaptability, so you can hire dependable staff and reduce turnover.
What Should You Look for When Interviewing Restaurant Staff?
Overview
Hiring the right staff is one of the most critical decisions you make as a restaurant owner. In an industry where turnover rates consistently exceed 70% annually, a single poor hiring decision can set off a chain reaction - affecting service quality, team morale, and operational efficiency. On the flip side, the right hire can ease pressure on your existing team, improve guest satisfaction, and help stabilize your business in the long run.
But finding the right person isn't just about experience on paper. A polished resume doesn't always equal a reliable, hard-working employee. That's why the interview process is your best opportunity to look deeper - into a candidate's attitude, communication style, adaptability, and fit for your team.
Define the Role Clearly Before the Interview
Before you even schedule interviews, take a step back and clarify exactly what you're hiring for. It sounds simple, but many restaurant owners rush into interviews without outlining the specifics of the role - and that leads to mismatched expectations and poor hiring decisions.
Start by creating a clear job description. What are the core responsibilities? What are the expected hours? Is this a weekday lunch shift role, or does it require late-night weekend availability? These details matter because not every candidate is suited for every role, even if they've worked in a restaurant before.
For example, hiring a line cook requires a focus on speed, precision, and the ability to work under intense pressure. A host, on the other hand, needs excellent people skills and the ability to stay calm and organized during a rush. If you're hiring a server, the ideal candidate should be outgoing, efficient, and able to handle customer concerns without losing their cool. Each position demands a different mix of soft and hard skills.
Outlining these traits ahead of time will guide your interview questions. You'll be better equipped to spot gaps, ask targeted follow-ups, and evaluate whether the candidate truly aligns with your expectations. This also shows candidates you run an organized, professional operation - making your restaurant more appealing to quality talent.
Lastly, don't assume candidates will ask clarifying questions. Be proactive in communicating what the job entails. When both you and the applicant are clear on the role, you'll save time, avoid misunderstandings, and increase your chances of hiring someone who will stick around.
Innovative Restaurant Software Solutions
Modernize Your Recruitment Process with Altametrics
Look Beyond the Resume
In the restaurant industry, a resume can only tell you so much. While experience is helpful, it's not always a reliable predictor of performance. A candidate might have worked at five different restaurants in the past two years, but that could be a red flag rather than a sign of adaptability. What truly matters - especially in customer-facing or fast-paced roles - is attitude and work ethic.
During the interview, pay close attention to how the candidate speaks about past jobs. Do they show respect for former employers and coworkers, even if the experiences were challenging? Are they enthusiastic about working in hospitality, or do they seem like they're just looking for a paycheck? Positivity, resilience, and a willingness to learn are often more valuable than technical skills that can be trained.
Ask situational or behavioral questions to reveal work ethic. For example -
- "Tell me about a time you had to cover a shift last minute - how did you handle it?"
- "How do you stay focused during long or stressful shifts?"
- "Can you give an example of when you went above and beyond for a customer or team member?"
Look for signs of reliability, problem-solving, and a can-do attitude. These traits contribute directly to team morale and guest satisfaction.
Also, observe their demeanor during the interview. Did they arrive on time? Were they respectful and engaged? These small cues often reflect how seriously they'll take the job.
Prioritize Communication and Team Compatibility
Clear, respectful communication is the glue that holds a restaurant team together - especially during high-pressure shifts where timing, coordination, and customer satisfaction are all on the line. A candidate might have excellent technical skills, but if they struggle to communicate with coworkers or guests, it can quickly lead to tension, mistakes, and a drop in service quality.
During the interview, pay attention to how well the candidate expresses themselves. Do they listen actively? Do they answer your questions clearly and confidently? Are they able to describe past experiences in a way that shows reflection and insight? These signs indicate emotional intelligence, which is a strong predictor of teamwork and adaptability in fast-paced environments.
You should also explore how they've worked with others in the past. Ask questions like -
- "Tell me about a time you had to collaborate with someone who had a different working style."
- "How do you handle conflicts or disagreements at work?"
- "What role do you usually play in a team setting - leader, supporter, problem-solver?"
Their responses can reveal whether they're a team player or more focused on individual performance. Compatibility with your current staff is just as important as their ability to handle tasks. A single disruptive employee can upset the flow of an entire shift.
Finally, remember that communication is a two-way street. Share your expectations around teamwork and communication culture. Make sure they feel aligned with your values. Building a cohesive team starts with people who not only do the job but elevate those around them.
Test for Problem-Solving and Adaptability
In the restaurant world, things rarely go exactly as planned. A dishwasher breaks down during dinner rush. A customer sends back an order. A team member calls in sick last minute. These are everyday realities, and they require staff who can stay calm, think on their feet, and adapt without escalating the situation.
During interviews, it's important to go beyond yes or no questions and test how candidates react in real-world scenarios. Hypothetical or situational questions can give you a clear picture of their decision-making process. For example -
- "What would you do if a customer was upset about a delayed order?"
- "If you were double-sat with tables during a rush, how would you manage both guests?"
- "How would you handle a situation where you were unfamiliar with a new system or menu item?"
What you're looking for isn't necessarily the "perfect" answer, but their thought process. Are they calm and logical? Do they consider both the customer and the team? Do they acknowledge responsibility or immediately shift blame?
Adaptability also means being open to feedback and willing to learn. Ask about a time they had to adjust quickly to a new system, menu, or manager. Do they show resistance to change or a growth mindset?
Problem-solving and adaptability are critical traits, especially in an environment where speed and flexibility are key to success. Hiring individuals who can troubleshoot under pressure helps prevent breakdowns in service - and gives you peace of mind when you're not on the floor.
Assess Availability, Reliability, and Schedule Fit
Even the most skilled, enthusiastic candidate won't be a good hire if their availability doesn't match your restaurant's needs. Misalignment in scheduling is one of the most common - and preventable - reasons new hires don't last. That's why discussing availability and reliability early in the interview is essential.
Start by clearly communicating the shifts that need to be covered. Are you looking for someone to handle late-night weekends, weekday lunch shifts, or a rotating schedule? Be specific. Don't assume candidates are flexible or willing to take whatever is offered - they may nod along during the interview and then struggle to commit once hired.
Ask direct questions like -
- "What days and hours are you available to work consistently?"
- "Are you available to work holidays or cover extra shifts if needed?"
- "Do you have any other commitments (school, another job, family responsibilities) that might affect your schedule?"
You should also explore their history of reliability. Ask, "Have you ever had to miss a shift unexpectedly? How did you handle it?" or "What would you do if you were running late?" Their responses will give insight into how dependable they are under pressure.
Another factor is transportation. Do they have a reliable way to get to and from the restaurant, especially during early or late shifts? If not, consider how that might affect attendance.
Hiring someone with the right skills but poor schedule fit leads to frustration - for you, your team, and the employee. Prioritizing availability and reliability during the interview helps ensure you hire someone who will show up, step up, and stick around.
Evaluate Hygiene, Presentation, and Professionalism
In a restaurant setting, first impressions matter - not just for customers but also for your team. The way a candidate presents themselves during the interview often reflects how they'll maintain personal hygiene and professionalism on the job. While it's important not to judge solely on appearance, some standards are non-negotiable, especially in roles involving food handling or direct customer interaction.
Cleanliness and grooming speak volumes about an employee's respect for their role and the environment. For example, a server with untidy clothing or poor personal hygiene could negatively impact the dining experience and even raise health concerns. Similarly, a kitchen staff member who disregards basic cleanliness might put food safety at risk.
During the interview, observe the candidate's grooming and attire as one signal of professionalism. Are they dressed neatly and appropriately for the role? Did they arrive on time and prepared? Professionalism also includes how they conduct themselves - polite greetings, eye contact, and attentive listening are positive signs.
However, be mindful of personal style and cultural differences - focus on hygiene and respectful behavior rather than rigid dress codes. Your goal is to find someone who understands and values the standards your restaurant upholds.
You can also set expectations early by explaining your dress code, grooming policies, and hygiene requirements. Candidates who respect these rules from the start are likely to be reliable in maintaining them on the job.
Interview With Purpose, Hire With Confidence
Interviewing restaurant staff is more than just ticking off a list of qualifications. It's about understanding who the candidate truly is - their attitude, work ethic, communication style, adaptability, and how well they'll fit within your team and operational needs. Taking the time to prepare, ask targeted questions, and observe carefully can help you avoid costly hiring mistakes and build a dependable, motivated workforce.
Remember, a thoughtful interview process is an investment. When you hire the right people, your restaurant runs smoother, turnover drops, and your guests leave happier. The right hires don't just fill positions - they become the backbone of your success.
If you're looking to take your hiring and workforce management to the next level, consider using tools designed specifically for restaurants. Altametrics offers a comprehensive platform to streamline scheduling, time tracking, and onboarding - helping you optimize your team's performance from recruitment to daily operations.
Learn how Altametrics can support your hiring process and overall restaurant management by clicking "schedule a Demo", so you can focus on what matters most - delivering great food and experiences to your guests.
Employee scheduling
The Complete Guide to Restaurant Employee Benefits
Accounting payroll
5 Signs Your Hotel Needs to Upgrade Its Payment Processing System
Restaurant management
The Ultimate Daily Checklist for Restaurant Owners
Accounting payroll
Are You Over-complicating Your Restaurants Payroll Process?
Inventory management
Is Your Inventory Management Costing You Profits?
Employee scheduling
How Can Smart Scheduling Transform Your Restaurant's Efficiency?
Restaurant management
What Are the Best Email Marketing Campaign Ideas for Restaurants in 2025?
Restaurant management
How Can You Maintain Brand Consistency Across Multiple Franchise Locations?
Employee scheduling
How Can Restaurants Prevent Scheduling Conflicts and Last-Minute Absences?
Restaurant management
What's the Most Efficient Way to Manage Tasks in a Busy Restaurant?
Employee scheduling
What Should You Look for When Interviewing Restaurant Staff?
Restaurant management
What Is a Dram Shop Law and How Does It Affect Your Restaurant?
Restaurant management
What Features Should Every Restaurant Ordering System Have in 2025?
Accounting payroll
What Are the Most Cost-Effective Ways to Reduce Waste in a Restaurant?
Inventory management
Are Your Menu Items Costing You More Than They're Worth?
Accounting payroll
How Do You Handle Overtime and Tip Credit in Restaurant Payroll?
Accounting payroll
Are You Spending Too Much Time on Payroll? Here's How to Fix it
Inventory management
How Can I Implement an Effective Inventory Management System in my Restaurant?
Sales forecasting
What Do Consumer Reports Say About Your Menu?
Inventory management
What Are the Main Inventory Costing Methods for Restaurants?
Restaurant management
How to Streamline Your Restaurants Supply Chain
Restaurant management
How to Optimize Order Fulfillment in Your Restaurant
Employee scheduling
How to Design an Effective Employee Training Program for Restaurants
Restaurant management
9 Essential Workforce Management Tools Every Restaurant Needs
Accounting payroll
How to Read and Use Your Restaurants Profit and Loss Statement
Accounting payroll
How to Organize Your Restaurant's Financial Records Efficiently
Accounting payroll
Restaurant Billing 101 - Simplify Your Finances and Boost Efficiency
Accounting payroll
The Ultimate Guide to Accounts Payable Automation for Restaurant Owners
Accounting payroll
Benefits of Accounts Receivable Automation for Restaurants
Accounting payroll
The Ultimate Guide to Restaurant Accounting
Accounting payroll
Restaurant Bookkeeping 101 - A Beginner's Guide for Restaurant Owners
Accounting payroll
Invoice Management 101 - A Simple Guide for Restaurant Owners
Restaurant management
What Are Par Levels and Why Every Restaurant Owner Should Care
Sales forecasting
Top 5 Consumer Metrics Every Restaurant Should Track
Inventory management
Which Inventory Method is Best for Your Restaurant?
Accounting payroll
Setting Up an Employee Loan Program in Your Restaurant
Employee scheduling
The Ultimate Employee Onboarding Checklist for Restaurant Owners
Accounting payroll
Top 7 Payroll Mistakes Restaurant Owners Should Avoid
Accounting payroll
How to Calculate Food Cost Variance in Your Restaurant
Sales forecasting
A Guide to Understanding Customer Behavior in Restaurants
Restaurant management
Top 10 California Employment Laws Every Restaurant Owner Must Know
Restaurant management
How to Create Custom Recipe Templates for Your Restaurant Kitchen
Restaurant management
5 Practical Strategies to Cut Food Waste in Your Restaurant
Restaurant management
Understanding Restaurant Food Cost Percentage in 2025 - Strategies for Profitability
Inventory management
The Restaurant Owner's Guide to Streamlining Supply Chain Processes
Restaurant management
How to Efficiently Calculate and Manage Labor Cost in Restaurants
Food safety
General Food Safety Guidelines for Restaurants
Inventory management
A Guide for Restaurant Food Suppliers
Employee scheduling
Key Elements of a Successful Restaurant Scheduling System
Restaurant management
How to Reduce Labor Costs in Your Restaurant Without Sacrificing Service
Inventory management
5 Best Practices for Food Inventory Management to Reduce Waste
Employee scheduling
Understanding California Overtime Laws for Restaurants
Employee scheduling
Top Features to Look for in an Electronic Time Clock for Restaurants
Restaurant management
The Best Employee Rewards Programs for Restaurants
Employee scheduling
The Best Time Keeping Methods for Restaurants
Employee scheduling
How a Restaurant Scheduling App Helps You Avoid Common Scheduling Mistakes
Employee scheduling
Features to Look for in a Clock-In Machine for Restaurants
Employee scheduling
How to Improve Time and Attendance Tracking in Your Restaurant
Employee scheduling
How California Work Week Laws Affect Restaurant Scheduling
Accounting payroll
Best Practices for Calculating Payroll Hours in Restaurants
Employee scheduling
How to Prevent Time Theft in Your Restaurant
Restaurant management
How Technology Can Improve Employee Management in Restaurants
Employee scheduling
California Employment Laws Every Hotel Owner Should Know in 2025
Restaurant management
California's Updated Overtime and Break Laws for Restaurants
Employee scheduling
10 Essential Work Schedules for Running a Smooth Restaurant Operation
Employee scheduling
How to Accurately Calculate Work Hours for Your Restaurant Staff
Employee scheduling
Best Practices for Managing Employee Time and Attendance in Restaurants
Employee scheduling
How to Create an Efficient Restaurant Weekly Schedule That Boosts Productivity
Software integration
Top 5 Benefits of Automating Your Business Workflows
Software integration
The Role of AI in Business Process Automation
Software integration
The Power of API Integrations - Connecting Your Business Tools Seamlessly
Software integration
The Importance of Seamless Integrations in Today's Business Landscape
Software integration
How Workflow Automation Can Save Small Businesses Thousands of Dollars
Software integration
How Any Connector Simplifies API Integrations for Your Business
Software integration
Empowering Your Employees with Automation- A Win-Win Strategy
Software integration
Building a Business Case for Automation in Your Organization
Employee scheduling
Automation in Hospitality - Streamlining Guest Experiences
Restaurant management
5 Ways Restaurants Can Leverage Automation for Operational Success
Sales forecasting
How to Double Your Restaurant's Profit in 30 Days
Inventory management
The Ultimate Guide to Accurate Inventory Counting in Restaurants
Restaurant management
How to Transform Your Restaurant Operations
Restaurant management
How to Effectively Reduce Expenses and Increase Staff Engagement in Your Restaurant
Employee scheduling
How to make sure you will always meet labor goals before you run payroll
Employee scheduling
How to reduce labor costs without retraining your management team.
Restaurant management
3 top reasons your managers should always earn their bonuses
Software integration
How to guarantee your franchise technology rollout will be a success
Employee scheduling
How to reduce labor costs by 3-5% without ever using an excel spreadsheet again
Employee scheduling
How to find and keep your best employees
Software integration
Why your IT team has to provide better mobile apps for you to stay competitive
Accounting payroll
How to streamline your business operations test for maximum efficiency
Software integration
How to make sure your technology projects are on time and on budget
Employee scheduling
Why employee engagement and retention are the keys to improving profitability
Employee scheduling
The easy way to write great employee schedules
Restaurant management
How to manage your restaurant inventory planning to ensure you're never caught short
Inventory management
5 Basic Inventory Management Tips That Can Save You Money
Inventory management
Top 3 Reasons Why You Need Cloud-Based Inventory Management Software
Restaurant management
The Best Food Service Management Companies in the Industry
Software integration
7 Tips for Choosing the Best Restaurant Directory Software
Food safety
What You Need to Know About Food Tech Safety
Employee scheduling
The Top 5 Reasons To Use HR Reporting Software
Food safety
A Guide On What To Know About SQF Food Safety
Inventory management
10 Inventory Management Stock Control Tips For Your Business
Restaurant management
Issues Facing Multi-Chain Restaurants In 2022
Employee scheduling
The Benefits of HR Software Reporting For Professionals
Employee scheduling
5 Top HR Software Solutions To Consider For Your Business
Software integration
5 Reasons Why You Need Restaurant Menu Software
Employee scheduling
Tips for Retaining Hourly Restaurant Employees
Employee scheduling
Hurdles That Keep Restaurant Chains From Becoming The Employer Of Choice
Accounting payroll
Why You Should Start Using Restaurant Payroll Software
Inventory management
How To Make The Most Out Of Your Simple Inventory Management Software
Restaurant management
Food Waste Management- 6 Strategies to Reduce the Impact of Food Waste
Food safety
CDC Food Safety- The Important Perspective
Food safety
What To Know About Taking A Food Safety Class
Inventory management
The Average Restaurant Food Cost Percentage & What You Can Do About It
Inventory management
Inventory Management Best Practices- A Guide to Controlling Your Inventory
Software integration
How to Choose the Right Restaurant Dashboard Software for Your Needs
Inventory management
5 Free Inventory Management Tools for Small Businesses
Food safety
How to Get a Food and Drink Handling License
Employee scheduling
3 Ways You Can Get Your Employees to Love Cloud-based HR and Payroll Software
Inventory management
5 Ways to Improve Your Multi Channel Inventory Management
Inventory management
5 Top Ways to Reduce Your Restaurant Fixed Costs
Inventory management
The Best Inventory Management Software- The Ultimate Guide
Food safety
What To Know About A Food Safety Course Online
Employee scheduling
The Best Free Employee Scheduling Apps to Help Your Business Run Smoothly
Food safety
How To Identify PHF Food Safety Anywhere You Are
Restaurant management
5 Tips for Choosing the Best Kitchen Equipment Supplier
Software integration
Mobile Device Inventory Management- A Guide to Help You Do It Right
Food safety
Food Safety Zone- A Guide to Safely Eating Out
Restaurant management
3 Tips to Find the Best Restaurant Paper Suppliers
Inventory management
Top Free Inventory Management Software for Small Businesses
Food safety
7 Ways To Become A Food Safety Auditor
Employee scheduling
5 Reasons You Should Be Using Free HR Software
Inventory management
4 Types of Inventory Management Systems and How They Affect Your Business
Employee scheduling
HR Recruitment Software- Why Restaurant Chains Fail To Become Preferred Choice
Restaurant management
Food Waste Management Solutions- The Ultimate Guide to Eliminating Food Waste
Employee scheduling
HR Software Solutions- Tips For Retaining Hourly Restaurant Employees
Accounting payroll
What You Need to Know About Restaurant Payroll Laws
Employee scheduling
HR Software List- The Best and the Worst
Restaurant management
How Restaurant Food Suppliers Are Important To A Business
Restaurant management
What Are The Best Restaurant Paper Goods Suppliers?
Inventory management
The Ultimate Guide to Inventory Management Techniques
Food safety
Food Safety Tips- How To Stay Safe at Home
Restaurant management
5 Questions to Ask Yourself Before Hiring a Food Service Management Company
Restaurant management
Ordering Management System- Issues Faced by Multi-Chain Restaurants In 2022
Food safety
Three Steps to Creating a Food Safety Plan
Employee scheduling
The Best Employee Time Clock Machines for Your Business
Employee scheduling
The Top 5 Reasons to Switch to Cloud Based HR Software
Employee scheduling
Our Top 5 Best Employee Scheduling Apps For Small Businesses
Food safety
Food Safety News- A Checklist for Safe Foods
Restaurant management
8 Tips for Successful Financial Management In Food Service
Software integration
5 Tips for Improving Your Data Integration Software
Food safety
5 Benefits of Food Safety That You Need to Know
Employee scheduling
The Best Employee Shift Planning Manager | Employee Scheduling & Shift Planning
Employee scheduling
Free Employee Time Clock to Give Your Business a Competitive Edge
Restaurant management
The Best Restaurant Produce Suppliers in America
Employee scheduling
HR Timesheet Software- What To Look For and How It Works
Restaurant management
Find the Best Restaurant Chemical Suppliers
Employee scheduling
Tracking Time Effectively- The Best HR Time Tracking Software
Accounting payroll
5 Best Business Accounting Software Reviews
Employee scheduling
5 Free Employee Scheduling Apps You Need to Try
Restaurant management
How to Find the Best Restaurant Coffee Suppliers
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of questions should I ask to assess problem-solving skills?
Use situational questions that present common restaurant challenges, like handling upset customers or managing a busy shift. This reveals how candidates think and respond under pressure.
How do I know if a candidate will fit well with my existing team?
Ask about their teamwork experience and how they handle conflict. Observe their communication style during the interview and consider whether their personality aligns with your team culture.
How can I spot red flags during a restaurant job interview?
Watch for inconsistent answers, negativity about previous employers, lack of enthusiasm, or vague responses. These may indicate potential issues with attitude or reliability.
What legal considerations should I keep in mind when interviewing restaurant staff?
Avoid questions about age, religion, marital status, or other protected characteristics. Focus solely on job-related qualifications.
